What are you looking for?

Big Brother Star Claims That Smacking Her Daughter, 12, Has Made Her Turn Out 'Fantastically Well' - But Others Insist There's 'No Excuse' To Hit A Child

Big Brother Star Claims That Smacking Her Daughter, 12, Has Made Her Turn Out 'Fantastically Well' - But Others Insist There's 'No Excuse' To Hit A Child

A Big Brother star has admitted to using smacking to discipline her daughter, and claims she's turned out better because of it.

Rebecca Jane, 32, said she had smacked 12-year-old Paris when her behaviour got 'out of control' in the past, and she'd tried other discipline techniques like putting her in a 'time out' or on the so-called naughty step.

She was speaking on This Morning during a debate following the announcement that Scotland is set to be the first part of the UK to ban smacking, after Nicola Sturgeon's government endorsed a proposed new law. 

Rebecca said she refused to let other people 'tell her how to parent', and insisted that her daughter was doing 'fantastically well' as a direct result of her disciplining.

But her comments were slammed by This Morning viewers, who said there was 'no excuse' to smack children.

Rebecca insisted that her daughter was doing 'fantastically well' because of being smacked. Pictured left to right: Rebecca, Paris and youngest daughter Peaches, five

 

The proposed legislation will remove the defence of 'justifiable assault' in Scots law, which allows parents to use physical punishment to admonish a child. 

Rebecca, who is also mum to Peaches, five, who she has never smacked - said that smacking is sometimes justified in extreme situations when children are behaving badly.

She said: 'It’s been very extreme measures when she's been completely and utterly out of control, it's used as distraction technique for them to address their behaviour. 

'It’s not just that, it’s about the threat of it and if they think that may happen to them then they will control their behaviour.'

 

Her comments were slammed by This Morning viewers on Twitter (pictured), who said there was 'no excuse' to smack children
Her comments were slammed by This Morning viewers on Twitter (pictured), who said there was 'no excuse' to smack children

 

Rebecca said she only gives her daughter a light smack on her bottom or arm and doesn't caused physical damage.

She blamed declining levels of smacking for the increasing levels of youth crime, saying that older generations committed less crime because they were disciplined.

She slammed the proposed legislation, and said she should be able to punish her children in any way she sees fit.

Rebecca continued: 'Lets us parent our children don’t tell us how to do it. I've got the best interests of my child at heart she’s turned out fantastically well and I perfectly agree with smacking.'

It was recently announced that Scotland is set to be the first part of the UK to ban smacking after Nicola Sturgeon's government endorsed a proposed new law. File photo

This Morning viewers took to criticise Rebecca for smacking her children, saying it's never justified.

One tweeted: 'There is no excuse for smacking children. All it shows to your child is that when you’re buttons are pressed, you can lash out. If you need to smack anyone, then you’ve lost control.'

'Smacking is wrong on every level, it’s violence towards an innocent child, a stern word and warning should be more than enough,' another posted.

A third said: 'Smacking your children will make them hate you and think it’s okay to deal with their anger with violence. Not rocket science, no one should be putting their hands on anyone.' 

 

 

We wanted to share this article with you to find out what your thoughts were? We found this here

 

"Just Three In Ten Parents Read Stories To Their Children Every Day" Read more

Activities

The Baby Website Downloads

Puffin Colouring

To download more activities from The Baby Website sign up to our premium membership.

Sign Up

Your Journey

Sausage Casserole

Sausage Casserole

brown the sausages in a pan, and move to an ovenproof dish Add in parboiled carrots Add in frozen …

Get inspired with our selected recipes
Full Recipe